Every year, right about now, we gather around the same uncomfortable reality: the budget. It’s the elephant in the room; not because anyone is ignoring it, but because it’s big, it’s complicated, and it has a habit of quietly consuming everything in sight. Public safety, roads, parks, water, staffing… all important, all competing, all wanting a seat at the table.
And then there’s the part no one loves: every dollar we spend in one place is a dollar we can’t spend somewhere else. There is no “miscellaneous magic fund.” Just choices. The budget is where all good ideas meet a limited checkbook.
What’s Changed This Year
Since we started this process, one thing has become clearer than ever: Over the past several years, Ivins has made a deliberate shift toward stronger, more professional public safety services. We moved from a largely volunteer fire model to full-time Fire/EMS staffing. At the same time, we’ve been strengthening a police department that had been operating very lean.
I support these decisions. They improve response times, reliability, and safety for our residents. But they also change the math. Public safety now makes up about 47% of our total budget, up from 39% eight years ago.
That doesn’t mean anything has gone wrong. It means we made a choice about what kind of city we want to be. But it does mean something important going forward: These are ongoing, structural costs. They don’t go away next year. They grow with staffing, training, equipment, and service expectations. That shift shows up clearly in this year’s budget.
The Budget Is Balanced… But Not Effortlessly
At a high level, the proposed budget is balanced. Revenues and expenses are close. But when you look a little closer, you see the tension. Overall expenses are up 3.6%. That’s even with an 18.5% increase in public safety costs, driven by adding personnel to improve response times and give us the ability to respond to two incidents at the same time.
Our Center Street Fire Station Remodel & Expansion
This brings us to one of the most important decisions currently in front of us: the remodel and expansion of the Center Street Fire Station.
This project wasn’t originally planned for the near term. However, a consultant study completed last fall made it clear that, with continued growth in Ivins and Santa Clara, our current facilities need a refresh to support the level of service our community needs.
We believe this project can be accommodated within our overall financial plan by delaying or reprioritizing some other capital projects. How much we will have to delay depends on how well we do with grants.
Mayor Smith will be presenting a “State of the City” update on May 7th from 11:30 AM to 1:00 PM at City Hall (85 N Main Street), which will include more information on the proposed fire station renovation and expansion. I encourage you to attend if you’re interested in learning more about this important project and how it fits into our broader plans for the city. (Refreshments will be served.)
What Residents Are Saying
One of the most valuable parts of this budget process for me personally has been hearing from residents. I appreciate the dozens of comments I’ve received and have looked at the budget through these ideas. The feedback I’ve received has been remarkably consistent:
- Prioritize public safety
- Maintain and improve roads and infrastructure
- Be careful and disciplined with spending
Those priorities don’t conflict… until they do. Because the budget is where they all compete with each other.
The Real Question We’re Facing
The question isn’t whether public safety is important. It is. The question is: How do we sustain a higher level of service over time without crowding out everything else?
That’s the balancing act. I believe we can balance these needs. But not without careful planning. That includes some tradeoffs, and hard conversations about priorities. That’s what is happening this budget season, which includes pushing off some capital projects into the future to make room for more urgent needs.
Why This Still Matters Right Now
And this brings us back to the most important point I’ve been making for the past few months: The best time to influence the budget is before the final public hearing on May 21st.
By the time we get to the public hearing, most of the major decisions will already be largely set. Not because anyone is ignoring input, but because the process naturally narrows options over time.
Right now, we still have flexibility. Right now, priorities can still shift. Right now, your input can still make a real difference.
What Would Help Most
You don’t need to read spreadsheets (unless you enjoy that sort of thing). Download the latest version of our tentative budget.
What’s most helpful is hearing your perspective: What city services matter most to you? Where should we be cautious about spending? What are we missing? What problems should we be planning for now?
If you have thoughts, questions, or concerns, I’d like to hear them. You don’t have to figure this out alone. I’m happy to email you any budget-related information I have, walk you through the budget, explain how things are funded, or talk through any issue.
Because when residents speak up early, we make better decisions together.
We have been discussing the budget at every meeting for a couple of months now and will discuss it again at our May 7th City Council meeting. We will also adopt a tentative budget at that meeting that will go to a public hearing at the next meeting on May 21st.
But don’t wait until the 21st. Please email me now with your thoughts. The elephant isn’t going anywhere. The question is how we manage it… together.
Sign up for monthly email updates (click here)
Never more than 12 emails a year and you can unsubscribe any time
Let me know about Ivins issues that are important to you.
Please email me with your concerns, ideas, suggestions, and recommendations.
________________
Recent “Finance” Articles
- What Should Ivins Fund First?PDF 📄When I wrote last month about budget season, I asked for early input before the formal public hearing in May. Many of you responded. Thank you. What I received wasn’t abstract commentary. It was specific, practical, sometimes passionate, sometimes skeptical, and always thoughtful. Residents raised concerns about infrastructure, growth, public safety, parks, water, roads,…
- Help Decide What Gets DonePDF 📄Now is the most important time to speak up about city priorities. We’ve entered budget season. I know, that sounds boring. Maybe it just needs better marketing. Something like: “If you are experiencing chronic uncertainty about city spending, ask your city council if BudgeTrex is right for you.” Funny name aside, this is actually…
- What Kind of City Do We Want?PDF 📄Your ballot for November’s election is asking whether to keep or repeal Ivins’ first property-tax increase in 15 years. No one enjoys paying more in taxes. But the real question isn’t simply, “Do I want a tax increase?” The real question is, “What kind of city do we want Ivins to be?” I personally…
- At a Fork in the Road: Choosing Ivins’ Future TogetherPDF 📄On August 14th, the City Council voted to approve an $860,000 property tax increase. This is the first increase in the Ivins portion of property taxes in 15 years. For an average Ivins home, valued at $743,247, this increase is roughly $10 a month. The council chambers were full for the public hearing about…
- Property Tax Increase: Where We Go From HerePDF 📄Update – August 25, 2025: Last week a resident filed a referendum petition, which, if it qualifies, will place the property tax increase on the November 4th ballot for voters to approve or reject. That means our budget, and our ability to meet city needs, could be up in the air until then. So,…